Who can afford the future?
Innovation
Technology
Consulting
Home » Who can afford the future?
16 November 2026
Alfredo Adamo
Alfredo Adamo
- Culture, Technology, Work and Society
I am beginning to distrust discussions about the future that cannot tell us how much it will cost to live there.
We can discuss artificial intelligence, automation, and virtual worlds for hours. Then someone has to go home, pay the rent, catch a bus, find someone to look after the children. It is in this transition that I measure the distance between the promise of progress and how it is actually distributed. And this is where Zohran Mamdani’s political project strikes me as interesting: it brings ambition down to the level of everyday life.
His platform set out recognizable goals: freezing rent increases in rent-stabilized housing, making buses free, providing universal childcare, creating city-owned grocery stores. These are different proposals, with different costs and challenges. Yet they share a common direction: reducing what a person has to spend to live and work in the city. Platform submitted to NYC Votes
It is a direction I want to compare with the visions of some leading figures in the technology industry. The comparison concerns power: who defines the problem, who chooses the solution, who can afford it.
Meredith Broussard calls the presumption that a computational solution is superior to the alternatives technochauvinism. What interests me most is the moment when this presumption moves beyond the technical realm and becomes a political hierarchy: those who know how to build a technology begin to consider themselves better qualified to decide how we should live, too. Broussard, Letting Go of Technochauvinism
Take transportation. In his 2016 Master Plan, Part Deux, Elon Musk envisioned autonomous vehicles, a shared Tesla fleet, and cars capable of generating income for their owners when they were not being used. The document also addressed mass transit: reducing it to a fantasy of cars for the wealthy would be unfair. But at the center of the transformation remained a technological system developed by the company, accessed through its products and services. Musk, Master Plan, Part Deux
Mamdani’s proposal for free buses shifts the starting point to the cost of access. One question concerns what a vehicle will be able to do; the other, what a person will be able to afford. Both matter. But for someone who needs to get to work tomorrow morning, the second has an urgency that no technological demonstration can erase.
A free bus that rarely comes would be a poor answer. Frequency, reliability, and funding are needed. This is precisely the ground on which I would like to judge innovation: how much time it gives back, how many opportunities it opens up, how many people it manages to serve.
The same applies to housing. In 2021, Mark Zuckerberg described a future in which we could appear at the office as holograms, avoiding the commute, and share experiences through the metaverse. Remote presence can have concrete value. But that promise also strikes me for what it leaves unresolved: to connect from home, I first need to be able to afford a home. Zuckerberg, Founder’s Letter, 2021
Tenant protections and an increase in the housing supply address that material prerequisite. Virtual work can reduce some geographical constraints; housing policy must address prices, availability, and relationships between landlords and tenants. Conflating the two allows a new technical possibility to be presented as a sufficient answer to a social problem.
When it comes to childcare, the comparison becomes even more concrete. The Mamdani administration has begun expanding free provision for two-year-olds as part of a path toward universal childcare. It is a process to be assessed by the places actually available, the quality, and educators’ working conditions. But the political choice is clear: collectively shouldering part of the cost of care. City of New York, childcare initiatives
Here I see an idea of productivity that deserves more attention. A parent who finds a reliable service can work, study, and choose more freely. The benefit comes from staff, facilities, and organization. Achieving it requires deciding who pays and who is entitled to access. Technology can help; the decision about distribution remains.
The city-owned grocery store project is even more open to criticism. The administration has announced prices averaging 30% below those of nearby stores for fresh produce and certain essential categories. It is a commitment to be verified once the stores are operating, alongside the public costs and the impact on surrounding businesses. City of New York, city-owned grocery store project
Yet the experiment raises a legitimate question: if the market leaves people without adequate access to food, what tools can a city use? Subsidies, support for existing stores, and public operation should be compared on results. Ruling out direct intervention from the outset means turning an economic preference into an impassable boundary for democracy.
This is where the comparison meets Marc Andreessen’s vision. In his Techno-Optimist Manifesto, technology and markets are the engine of growth and abundance. I recognize the strength of that argument. But I want to know through which institutions the promised abundance will become actual access. Overall growth, on its own, does not tell me who will be able to pay the rent. Andreessen, The Techno-Optimist Manifesto
My objection begins when we are asked to consider the interests of those funding innovation as a sufficient representation of collective interests. Entrepreneurial risk deserves a return. It does not confer a mandate to set everyone’s priorities.
Peter Thiel had already expressed the conflict explicitly in 2009, writing that he no longer believed freedom and democracy were compatible and looking to technology for a way out of politics. I do not attribute that position to every technology executive. But I do consider it a warning: for some, the freedom to build the future may include the desire to remove it from collective decision-making. Thiel, The Education of a Libertarian
Conclusion
Mamdani will have to demonstrate that his policies work. I would not give him a pass for an inefficient service simply because it is public. I would demand transparent accounts, measurable results, and the ability to correct course. It is the same standard I apply to those who promise to transform the world through a company.
What interests me about Mamdani’s project is the possibility of questioning the order of priorities. Before asking people to adapt to the next revolution, we can make their present lives sustainable. Housing, mobility, and care are also the conditions that allow people to participate in change rather than be subjected to it.
The future interests me. I would like to get there without being pushed out of the city I live in.
Index
Iscriviti alla newsletter
Indice
Iscriviti alla newsletter
Get more information
Home » Who can afford the future?